Educator + Author Dr. Carol Horn

Who she is: Dr. Carol V. Horn is coordinator of Advanced Academics Program (former Gifted and Talented Programs) for Fairfax County Public Schools in Northern Virginia.

What she does: She has worked in gifted education for the past 20 years and has a Master of Education in Educational Psychology with an Emphasis on Gifted from the University of Virginia. She earned her doctorate in Teacher Preparation and Special Education from The George Washington University and is the 2002 recipient of the Hollingsworth Award from the National Association for Gifted Children for outstanding research study in the field of gifted education.

Clever Analogies: Practice Making Creative Connections

By Dr. Carol Horn
K-12 Program Coordinator Department of Instructional Services
Fairfax County Public Schools

Editor’s note: The following is excerpted from Dr. Horn’s upcoming book, “The 10 Big Ideas: How to help your child think bigger, imagine more, and do better in school”

Innovation and creative thinking are valuable skills that are needed in today’s workforce.

A facility for working with analogies gives children a structure for generating creative ideas, seeing complex relationships, and making unusual comparisons.

Analogies are a powerful thinking tool because they build on the brain’s natural inclination to draw connections and comparisons as we learn new material, deepen our insights, and apply creative thinking in our everyday lives. They not only stimulate the imagination, they also lead children to deeper understandings by connecting things that do not always appear connected.

There are three kinds of analogy that may be used to stretch and extend children’s thinking, and each one becomes more complex as it is applied.

1. The Direct Analogy

My Best Friend Is as Sharp as a Pencil is a lighthearted picture book in which a child describes her teachers and friends by comparing them to common objects, for example, one friend is quiet like a fish and another is clever like Legos. Through the use of analogies, the author has the child create a portrait of her school day that is creative, humorous, and engaging to readers.

It’s important to note that simple analogies are different from similes because their purpose is to find an unexpected similarity between unrelated things rather than just compare two things.

After reading the book, you may ask your child to describe their own friends using comparisons. When asked to do this, one young boy replied that his friend is like a monkey because he is silly but also like a tornado because he has strong opinions. Another young girl who was asked to use direct analogies to describe her dog said, “Her fur is like a carpet when I pet her because she is so soft, and her ears are like leaves because they flap in the wind.”

Picture books are fun to read and provide practice in understanding and applying analogies. Animology: Animal Analogies, by Marianne Berkes and Cathy Morrison, is a fun rhyming book that compares and contrasts very different animals by pointing out their similarities.

Once children understand how analogies work, there are numerous questions and sentence-starters that may be used to stimulate the imagination and lead them to deeper understandings by connecting things that do not always appear connected.

Examples include:

• Which geometric shape is most like you? Explain.
• Books are like gardens because …
• How is a friendship like a river?
• How is solving a problem like riding a bike?
• How are math problems like explorations in the New World?

Another strategy for working with analogies is using pictures to stimulate creative thinking and expression. For example, you can spread photographs from old calendars and magazines on a table and ask children to choose pictures that best describe them and explain why.

One teacher did this with her students, asking each one to select a picture that described him or her as a learner. One student picked a flower and said, “The flower shows how I learn because I learn little by little and so bud by bud.” Another child chose a city because, “When I am thinking about something, a lot goes on in my head, just like a city,” and another chose dominoes falling because, “I have to make mistakes a lot of times before I reach the end. The dominoes also are like when I fall down I have to pick myself up again.”

2. The Personal Analogy

This type of thinking challenges children to become the object of comparison and includes questions such as how does it feel to be a volcano, a Lego, or a snowstorm? The focus is on feelings, and it is an exercise that gives children an opportunity to empathize with the object, become personally involved, and express different feelings.

Children are asked how it would feel to be the object and why. For example, one child was asked how it would feel to be a Lego. Responses included:

  • “Creative, because I am part of a structure,”
  • “Insignificant, because no one notices me by myself,”
  • “Crowded, because I am in a pile with a bunch of different Legos,”
  • “Colorful like a rainbow,”
  • “Lonely when I am stored,”
  • “Excited because somebody might build something with me,”
  • “Suspended because people might stack me or leave me somewhere,”
  • “Important because every part is needed,” and
  • “Trapped because I am connected to other Legos.”

3. The Symbolic Analogy

This type of analogy is more complex and builds on the thinking of the first two types of analogy, the direct and the personal.

It is created by asking a child to put together opposite feelings that were listed in the personal analogy that seem to conflict or are charged with tension. Together these feelings create an oxymoron and stimulate creative thinking. For example, in the responses about how it feels to be a Lego, a child might put together Insignificant/Important, Creative/Crowded, Excited/Lonely, or Suspended/Trapped.

The symbolic analogy is created by asking children to think of an object that captures one pair of feelings. For example, one child said that a bicycle is excited and lonely—excited when it is out exploring the world, and lonely when it is put away waiting to be ridden. Another said that a ceiling fan is excited when it is spinning around and lonely when it is turned off because it just hangs from the ceiling.

The final step in the symbolic analogy is to ask a child to compare the object associated with the paired feelings to a topic or concept. For example, children asked how thinking is like a bicycle gave the following responses:

  • “Thinking is exciting because the ideas go around and around,”
  • “They are both useful,”
  • “A bicycle has different gears and there are different types of thinking,”
  • “Sometimes a bike goes fast and sometimes slow and same with thinking,”
  • “Someone can help you ride your bike and someone can help you be a better thinker,”
  • “Sometimes you ride with others and sometimes you ride alone and thinking is the same,” and
  • “They are both fun!”

The Bottom Line

Analogies help children see relationships and connections among objects and ideas in an original light. Creating and connecting with analogies enhances flexible thinking and helps children see the world in new and unusual ways. New ideas emerge and new approaches to solving a problem may surface—the possibilities are endless.

Never underestimate the power of analogies to capture and stimulate the imagination of a child!